| Platinum | Daydream Donuts Cafè |
| Platinum | Sweet Sensations |
| Platinum | The Mad Batter |
| Gold | Cait's Sweet Bites & Beanery |
| Silver | Wolfgangs Pastry Shop |
| Bronze | The Cookie Attic |
| Top Pick | Black House Bakery |
| Top Pick | COBS Bread Bakery |
| Top Pick | Fabulous Cakes by Jenn |
| Top Pick | Sandi's Cupcake Creations |