| Platinum | Red Tomato Pie |
| Gold | Betulla Burning |
| Silver | Nelly's Pub |
| Bronze | Fresh Tomato Pie |
| Bronze | Jolley Market Foods |
| Top Pick | Bonnet Eatery |
| Top Pick | Boston Pizza |
| Top Pick | CrossRoads Brewing & Distillery |
| Top Pick | DaddyO's Pizza & Ribs |
| Top Pick | Lil Ava's |